Waupaca County Post

Top Menu

  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • Advertiser Index
  • Subscribe
  • E-Editions
    • Clintonville Shoppers Guide
    • Clintonville Tribune Gazette
    • New London Buyers Guide
    • New London Press Star
    • Waupaca Buyers Guide
    • Waupaca County Post

Main Menu

  • Home
  • News
    • Video
    • Clintonville News
    • Hortonville News
    • Iola-Scandi News
    • Manawa News
    • New London News
    • Waupaca News
    • Wega-Fremont News
    • Business
  • Covid 19
  • Sports
    • Clintonville Sports
    • Iola-Scandy Sports
    • Manawa Sports
    • New London Sports
      • Leagues
      • Sports
      • Park & Rec Activities
    • Waupaca Sports
    • Wega-Fremont Sports
    • Hortonville Sports
    • Outdoor
    • High School Sports Scores
  • Courts
  • Opinion
  • Obits
  • Classifieds
    • View Ads
    • Place Ads
  • Legal Ads
    • Our Legals
    • Statewide
  • E-Editions
    • Clintonville Shoppers Guide
    • New London Buyers Guide
    • Waupaca Buyers Guide
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • Advertiser Index
  • Subscribe
  • E-Editions
    • Clintonville Shoppers Guide
    • Clintonville Tribune Gazette
    • New London Buyers Guide
    • New London Press Star
    • Waupaca Buyers Guide
    • Waupaca County Post

logo

Waupaca County Post

  • Home
  • News
    • Video
    • Clintonville News
    • Hortonville News
    • Iola-Scandi News
    • Manawa News
    • New London News
    • Waupaca News
    • Wega-Fremont News
    • Business
  • Covid 19
  • Sports
    • Clintonville Sports
    • Iola-Scandy Sports
    • Manawa Sports
    • New London Sports
      • Leagues
      • Sports
      • Park & Rec Activities
    • Waupaca Sports
    • Wega-Fremont Sports
    • Hortonville Sports
    • Outdoor
    • High School Sports Scores
  • Courts
  • Opinion
  • Obits
  • Classifieds
    • View Ads
    • Place Ads
  • Legal Ads
    • Our Legals
    • Statewide
  • E-Editions
    • Clintonville Shoppers Guide
    • New London Buyers Guide
    • Waupaca Buyers Guide
New London NewszHideFeatured
Home›News›New London News›New London man prevails in Supreme Court case

New London man prevails in Supreme Court case

By Waupaca Now
July 10, 2019
3934
0

Outcome limits Department of Public Instruction’s rulemaking authority

By Scott Bellile


Martinson

A Wisconsin State Supreme Court Case ended in a New London plaintiff’s favor.

The Supreme Court on June 25 issued a 4-2 decision in Koschkee v. Taylor that sided with the Milwaukee-based conservative law firm Wisconsin Institute for Law and Liberty.

Two years ago, New London resident Chris Martinson, two Wisconsin teachers and a school board member joined WILL in suing the state Department of Public Instruction over its alleged violation of 2017 Wisconsin Act 57, also known as the Regulations from the Executive in Need of Scrutiny Act.

The state Legislature in 2017 passed the REINS Act, which requires state agencies such as the DPI to submit to the Department of Administration scope statements laying out their visions for new administrative rules before proposing or drafting those rules. The DOA then assesses if the state agency has the authority to make that rule.

The DOA makes a non-binding recommendation to the governor, who may then decide whether to grant the agency written approval to make the rule.

In 2017, WILL sued then-State Superintendent Tony Evers. WILL alleged the Democrat and his DPI did not follow these procedures with then-Republican Gov. Scott Walker.

The state superintendent – first Evers, until he was elected governor in 2018, then his successor, Carolyn Stanford Taylor – and the DPI argued the governor’s approval on scopes is unnecessary because no state officer can act as the state superintendent’s superior with regard to the supervision of public instruction.

In last week’s majority opinion, the Supreme Court wrote rulemaking is a legislative power that is delegated to the state superintendent, so the Legislature may limit or take that power away from the superintendent as it chooses.

“We conclude that the gubernatorial approval requirement for rulemaking is constitutional as applied to the (state superintendent) and DPI,” the majority opinion states.

Siding with WILL were the court’s conservative justices: Chief Justice Patience Roggensack, Annette Ziegler, Rebecca Bradley and Daniel Kelly.

Dissenting were two liberal justices, Rebecca Dallet and Ann Bradley. The court’s third liberal justice, Shirley Abrahamson, withdrew from participation.

Martinson calls outcome a ‘victory’

In a statement, Martinson called the Supreme Court’s decision “a victory for self-governance, the rule of law, and for constitutional checks and balances.”

“Tony Evers and his successor thought they could make the laws without oversight from the legislature and the executive branch,” Martinson stated. “I applaud the Wisconsin Supreme Court for restoring accountability to the Department of Public Instruction. This outcome begs the question: how can citizens trust the DPI to set standards for k-12 education, when its leaders have forgotten basic civics?”

Joining Martinson as petitioners in WILL’s lawsuit were Kristi Koschkee, Pleasant Prairie teacher; Amy Rosno, virtual educator and former Burlington teacher; and Mary Carney, former Marshfield School Board member.

School board not part of suit

When Martinson became a petitioner in 2017, he was serving on the New London School Board.

Some board members were displeased at the time because the petition identified him as a New London School Board member. Board members worried people learning about his involvement in the news would conclude Martinson was suing Evers and the DPI on behalf of the New London School Board.

“His decision to take sides in a politically charged topic as stated in the petition as a member of the New London School Board has the potential of causing unrest with our staff, community and board, as well as causing harm to our working relationship with colleagues and state representatives,” then-School Board President Kim Schroeder told the board in December 2017.

This resulted in the school board issuing a statement clarifying Martinson was participating in the lawsuit as an individual, not an elected official.

“It is important to know that the School District of New London, inclusive of its staff, teachers, administrators and board of education, has not authorized this lawsuit and is not a party to it, nor will it spend taxpayer dollars or resources on such litigations,” the school board wrote in a letter to the Press Star.

Martinson stressed last week that he “sued as an individual citizen, not on behalf of the school board.” (New London area residents voted Martinson off the school board in April.)

Reactions around the state

Gov. Evers expressed disappointment in a statement regarding the Supreme Court’s ruling.

Evers

He issued a statement saying the Supreme Court in 2016 decided the state superintendent had the authority to propose rules without the governor’s oversight in Coyne v. Walker, a case regarding 2011 Wisconsin Act 21.

“Both conservative and liberal justices agreed then that the constitution prevented the governor from vetoing rules overseeing public schools,” Evers stated. “The facts didn’t change in the last three years and neither did the meaning of the constitution. Only the composition of the court did.”

State Superintendent Stanford Taylor also issued a statement disagreeing with the Supreme Court.

“The Wisconsin Supreme Court’s decision does not affect the constitutional independence of the Office of the State Superintendent. It is limited to rulemaking,” Stanford Taylor stated. “While I am disappointed, we remain committed to Wisconsin schools and students and will continue our work to ensure each student is college and career ready.”

Meanwhile, WILL said in a press release the Legislature has increasingly delegated rulemaking authority to state agencies, so the Supreme Court’s 4-2 decision demonstrates it is “important to limit agency discretion so as not to create a runaway administrative state.”

“Given that the DPI has generally been a captive of the educational establishment and hostile to school choice, this decision is a huge victory for Wisconsin’s kids,” WILL President and General Counsel Rick Esenberg said in a statement. “It is also a huge win for democratic government, the separation of powers, and public accountability.”

TagsChris MartinsonDPIGov. Tony EversNew London School BoardnewsletterSupreme Court
Previous Article

No free meeting space for Pigeon Lake ...

Next Article

Clintonville strength training program draws youth

Related articles More from author

  • New London News

    Lower taxes from New London schools

    September 24, 2015
    By WaupacaNow
  • Around Waupaca CountyNew London News

    New London schools raise tax rate

    November 4, 2015
    By WaupacaNow
  • Around Waupaca CountyNew London News

    State bill will impact schools

    December 29, 2015
    By WaupacaNow
  • Around Waupaca CountyNew London News

    Bill restricts school referendums

    January 20, 2016
    By WaupacaNow
  • New London News

    New member on school board

    June 22, 2016
    By WaupacaNow
  • New London NewsNews

    DPI candidate to speak in New London

    February 27, 2017
    By Waupaca Now

Leave a reply Cancel reply

Free WaupacaNow Newsletter

About Us


Waupaca County Post, New London Press Star and Clintonville Tribune-Gazette are published every Thursday by Multi Media Channels. The papers are locally owned, locally operated and locally written. Subscriptions are $59 annually, delivered via U.S. Postal Service.

To subscribe, go www.shopmmclocal.com/product-category/waupacanow-portal or call 715-258-4360

Timeline

  • July 1, 2022

    Volunteers help make trail projects a reality

  • July 1, 2022

    Governor visits New London

  • June 30, 2022

    Schneider, David J.

  • June 30, 2022

    Kutchenriter, Thomas Lee

  • June 30, 2022

    Iola gets new Ice Age Trail section

Find us on Facebook

Copyright © 2022 Multi Media Channels LLC.
All Rights Reserved. No part of this publication or any of its contents may be reproduced, copied, modified or adapted without the prior written consent of Multi Media Channels LLC.
×