Waupaca County Post

Top Menu

  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • Advertiser Index
  • Subscribe
  • E-Editions
    • Clintonville Shoppers Guide
    • Clintonville Tribune Gazette
    • New London Buyers Guide
    • New London Press Star
    • Waupaca Buyers Guide
    • Waupaca County Post

Main Menu

  • Home
  • News
    • Video
    • Clintonville News
    • Hortonville News
    • Iola-Scandi News
    • Manawa News
    • New London News
    • Waupaca News
    • Wega-Fremont News
    • Business
  • Covid 19
  • Sports
    • Clintonville Sports
    • Iola-Scandy Sports
    • Manawa Sports
    • New London Sports
      • Leagues
      • Sports
      • Park & Rec Activities
    • Waupaca Sports
    • Wega-Fremont Sports
    • Hortonville Sports
    • Outdoor
    • High School Sports Scores
  • Courts
  • Opinion
  • Obits
  • Classifieds
    • View Ads
    • Place Ads
  • Legal Ads
    • Our Legals
    • Statewide
  • E-Editions
    • Clintonville Shoppers Guide
    • New London Buyers Guide
    • Waupaca Buyers Guide
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • Advertiser Index
  • Subscribe
  • E-Editions
    • Clintonville Shoppers Guide
    • Clintonville Tribune Gazette
    • New London Buyers Guide
    • New London Press Star
    • Waupaca Buyers Guide
    • Waupaca County Post

logo

Waupaca County Post

  • Home
  • News
    • Video
    • Clintonville News
    • Hortonville News
    • Iola-Scandi News
    • Manawa News
    • New London News
    • Waupaca News
    • Wega-Fremont News
    • Business
  • Covid 19
  • Sports
    • Clintonville Sports
    • Iola-Scandy Sports
    • Manawa Sports
    • New London Sports
      • Leagues
      • Sports
      • Park & Rec Activities
    • Waupaca Sports
    • Wega-Fremont Sports
    • Hortonville Sports
    • Outdoor
    • High School Sports Scores
  • Courts
  • Opinion
  • Obits
  • Classifieds
    • View Ads
    • Place Ads
  • Legal Ads
    • Our Legals
    • Statewide
  • E-Editions
    • Clintonville Shoppers Guide
    • New London Buyers Guide
    • Waupaca Buyers Guide
CourtsFeatured
Home›Courts›Judge delays felony trial

Judge delays felony trial

By WaupacaNow
June 13, 2022
1285
0

Nielsen seeks records on McClone’s firing

By Robert Cloud

Judge Troy Nielsen postponed a jury trial in response to concerns regarding the Waupaca County Sheriff’s Office altering investigative reports before forwarding them to the district attorney’s office.

The trial was scheduled to start on July 11.

Attorney David Winkel represents Devin Postel, who was charged in July 2019 with second-degree sexual assault of an unconscious victim and felony bail jumping.

Winkel filed a motion asking Nielsen to require the sheriff’s office to appear in court and either “certify that the reports were not altered or provide the defendant with evidence in the form of written reports or otherwise of what was removed or altered from the reports.”

Winkel’s motion also requested that Nielsen order the sheriff’s office to “state under oath and cross-examination why Detective Pat McClone has been fired, to make sure the firing does not involve withheld evidence in this case.”

If the sheriff’s office refuses to comply, the court should dismiss the charges, according to the motion.

In his motion, Winkel noted that staff from the sheriff’s office testified on Feb. 21 that “reviewing officers not present for the investigation routinely altered reports of the investigating officer. The changes are not merely grammatical. Rather, staff testified that the changes may be substantive. In at least one case, reviewing officers removed exculpatory information.”

Defendants “have no way of confirming whether the probable cause established through the Waupaca County Sheriff’s Office reports is truthful and accurate, manufactured, or whether obviously exculpatory information has been removed,” Winkel argued.

“I don’t think my client is going to get a fair trial,” Winkel said at a hearing Thursday, June 9.

Winkel is asking the court to review McClone’s termination because McClone was the lead investigator in the case against Postel.

While she opposed dismissing the case against Postel, District Attorney Veronica Isherwood said at the hearing she agreed with “the vast majority of the motion.”

Isherwood said that the original report she received “has a big, red stamp on it that says ‘Revised.’”

A second report from the sheriff’s office did not indicate there had been revisions, Isherwood said.

Isherwood said she wants justice for the victim, but she also wants a fair trial for the defendant.

Evidentiary hearing

After Nielsen read Winkel’s motion, he sent a letter to Isherwood ordering her to provide all investigative records related to Postel’s case.

McClone authored most of the documents, which included reports on contacts with witnesses and the crime lab, search warrants and chain of custody.

Nielsen said McClone may need to testify at an evidentiary hearing that will focus not on the systemic issue of altering reports, but on this specific case.

The judge also ordered the sheriff’s office and the county’s human resources office provide records regarding McClone’s termination by June 16.

Nielsen will review McClone’s records “in camera,” which means they will not be open to the public. If the records are relevant, Nielsen will disseminate them to the district attorney and the defense counsel.

In criminal cases, mental health records, school, child welfare and medical records are not shared with the public.

Due to the sheriff’s election this year, Winkel questioned whether jurors would bring their prejudices to the trial.

“Now, it’s going to be political,” Winkel said.

Although he did not issue an order to change venue or set a specific date for the trial during the June 9 hearing, Nielsen also noted the controversy in the community regarding the sheriff’s office.

“No way on earth we could pick a fair and impartial jury from this county next month,” he said.

Attorneys issue letter

Winkel’s motion to dismiss a case based on concerns that altered reports may have removed exculpatory information will not be the last.

In a June 8 letter to all three Waupaca County judges, Sheriff Tim Wilz and Isherwood, the Waupaca County Defense Bar said it will file a uniform motion in all cases involving the sheriff’s office.

The letter said Wilz testified on Feb. 21 that his department’s conduct routinely resulted in Brady violations.

“The statement was either a reckless effort to downplay the violation or an accurate description of the operations of the department,” the letter said. “Either way it cannot be ignored by this section of the bar without inviting ethical and constitutional repercussions. The sheriff’s statement is now part of the public record and as such it triggers a duty of care on behalf of our clients.”

Tagsnewsletter
Previous Article

Carpenter, Lamont Monty “Max” R.

Next Article

Fire at food plant

Related articles More from author

  • Around Waupaca County

    WCI members in transition

    December 22, 2017
    By WaupacaNow
  • Courts

    Teen faces drug charges

    December 26, 2017
    By WaupacaNow
  • Waupaca News

    Foundry workers earn degrees

    December 27, 2017
    By WaupacaNow
  • CourtszHideFeatured

    Kidnap victim finds justice

    December 27, 2017
    By WaupacaNow
  • Waupaca News

    Catalpa opens in Waupaca

    December 28, 2017
    By WaupacaNow
  • Waupaca News

    Evans Street project planned

    December 28, 2017
    By WaupacaNow

About Us


Waupaca County Post, New London Press Star and Clintonville Tribune-Gazette are published every Thursday by Multi Media Channels. The papers are locally owned, locally operated and locally written. Subscriptions are $59 annually, delivered via U.S. Postal Service.

To subscribe, go www.shopmmclocal.com/product-category/waupacanow-portal or call 715-258-4360

Timeline

  • June 28, 2022

    Oestreich, Emily Elizabeth

  • June 28, 2022

    Armed standoff in Clintonville

  • June 27, 2022

    Mehlberg, Elaine

  • June 27, 2022

    Cierzan, Roy

  • June 27, 2022

    Kirchner (Witt), Nancy Yvonne

Find us on Facebook

Copyright © 2022 Multi Media Channels LLC.
All Rights Reserved. No part of this publication or any of its contents may be reproduced, copied, modified or adapted without the prior written consent of Multi Media Channels LLC.
×